Reviews

I loved working with Dana!! She was patient, answered all my questions, the cookies were delicious, and my family was thrilled with the design! Will order again soon xoxox

— Michelle May 2026

I am incredibly picky when it comes to custom baked goods because so often they look beautiful but taste like cardboard. These are the best custom cookies you're going to find in Plumas Lake. Highly recommended!!! Thanks Dana!!!

— Janet P Mar 2026

We ordered several dozen customized cookies from Dana for a local real estate event, and they were a massive hit! Organizing a large order can be stressful, but communication was quick, clear, and professional from day one. Arranging pickup was a breeze, and everything was wrapped safely for transport so not a single cookie was damaged. They looked like a work of art and tasted even better. Highly, highly recommend for any special occasion! Reach out to Horizon Property Partners for your next home purchase and we'll bring the cookies! Thanks, Dana!!

— Horizon Property Partners Jan 2026

Dreams of Buttercream is honestly the absolute best! I sent over a couple of reference pictures for my son’s birthday theme, and she completely brought the vision to life. The cookies were beautifully detailed, incredibly soft, and tasted amazing. My family was thrilled! I will never go anywhere else for custom cookies.

— Megan Jun 2025

Dana is an exceptional baker, her cookies are made from scratch using the freshest ingredients. I usually am not a cookie lover, but after tasting hers, I couldn’t believe how delicious it was!!

— Pam Denham May 2025

I cannot say enough amazing things about Dana and Dreams of Buttercream! I ordered a custom set of cookies for my daughter's graduation, and they completely stole the show. The attention to detail on the school logos was incredible, and they matched the school colors flawlessly. Not only were they gorgeous, but they were also hands-down the most delicious sugar cookies we've ever tasted. They came individually wrapped, so thoughtful! Every single guest asked where I got them. Thank you for making our celebration so sweet!

— Sarah K Feb 2025

Amazing! Customizable! Great communication and absolutely delicious desserts. I will never go another place. Thank you so much for making my sons party a perfect success.

— Nicole Marie Mar 2022

I want to give a big shout out for Dreams of Buttercream!! I Ordered these amazing hand made customized cookies for a baby shower, and they were so so beautiful with such care given to every detail. They were the exact color and design I asked for. Arranging pickup was fast and easy and the cookies were individually wrapped and packed in a box for safe transport. Everyone raved over them and wanted to know where I got them. They were so excited to get their thank you favor for coming. I highly recommend Dreams of Buttercream for your next special occasion.

— Donna Mueller Feb 2022

Dreams of Buttercream is honestly the best! Her cookies are so pretty & professional. Not to mention they taste delicious. I was referred by a friend, and I am not disappointed. She had the cookies ready & individually wrapped for me. She also sent me updates on them while she was making them. I will definitely order more for my kids’ future parties! I am so impressed honestly. I love Dreams of Buttercream, you will not be disappointed.

— Mayra Alejandra Apr 2019

Definitely a recommendation I would give to anyone looking for a reliable baker. The cookies tasted delicious homemade and the design was exactly what I had asked for! Very prompt with delivery and i will definitely be using again ! Thank you so much ‘ you made my baby shower amazing

— AmandaLee Stevens Dec 2018

I give her 5 stars because was the product not only adorable but it tasted yummy too!! Thank you Dana

— Lena De La Torre Jun 2018