Dreams of Buttercream — custom decorated sugar cookies in Plumas Lake, California
Fastest way to reach us
Not on either? Use the contact form →
Made to order
Every order is custom. Tell us the occasion, colors, and any details you have in mind — we'll bring it to life in icing.
Rush & last-minute welcome
Orders start at a half dozen. Seven days is ideal, but we love a challenge—ask about last-minute, rush, and same-day orders. See pricing and how to order →
Delivery & shipping
Free local pickup, local delivery for a small fee, or shipped anywhere in the U.S. — heat-sealed to arrive fresh. From $12, free at 4+ dozen. Shipping details →
What customers say
★★★★★ 5 from 20 reviews
-
★★★★★
I ordered cookies LAST MINUTE because another baker cancelled on me. They did an amazing job and I'm very happy -- this will be my new GO-TO specialty cookie place. Thank you! How do I leave a tip?
-
★★★★★
My best friend ordered cookies for me from another baker, who cancelled our order for my engagement party the morning of. She found dreams of buttercream on Facebook & messaged her, out of 20 people she was the only one to say yes to such a last minute order! We are so grateful and the cookies were stunning and delicious! Everyone loved them, and one of the best custom sugar cookies I have ever had. Thank you so much!
-
★★★★★
Dreams of Buttercream did an awesome job on the custom cookies for our birthday party. The design was exactly what I asked for, and they tasted just as good as they looked. My boss was super impressed. Everything was ready on time, boxed safely, and individually wrapped, which made it easy to hand out to guests. Communication was solid from start to finish and Dana sent progress pictures as she created. I highly recommend her if you need custom cookies for any event. 💪
